
Let me prefix this post by saying that I have not used
Banshee since its infancy--and that it has clearly come a long way. I have been a devoted
Rhythmbox user for several years. Previously, I have been known to use
MPD with a myriad of different frontends. Banshee is under active development, with new features being added constantly. Unfortunately, I cannot say the same for Rhythmbox. Since updating to Ubuntu 8.10, I've decided to make the switch to Banshee.
Initially, I noticed an improved startup time over my previous stint with Banshee--from about 1 minute to a whopping 5 seconds. I'm sure this improvement is not solely for Banshee, however--I am on a slightly faster computer, and I'm sure updates to Mono have made it more efficient.
The user interface has some good points and some flaws. First, the good: it's very streamlined, well organized, and just plain pretty to look at. Conversely, it has some bad parts: the "Next" button icon should never change, the seek bar is far too small, and it does not jump to the currently playing song (nor does it provide such an option).
I do not like most of the keybindings; I am used to the "find as you type" search that Rhythmbox supports, which means I often find myself hitting N, R, or T, only to find out I am not searching, but instead opening a dialog or changing/restarting the song. I would really kill to have Alt+Left and Alt+Right as previous/next keybindings, too.
I really don't want video support. I have a video player for that. What can I do to get rid of it from the left menu?
Overall, I'd say it's a superior player to Rhythmbox now. I look forward to overcoming the quirks I listed, or finding ways to customize it to fit my needs.